Hamilton: Carmelo Anthony Isn’t Overrated, But He Is Overvalued

NEW YORK — It’s amazing how history repeats itself. Once again, Carmelo Anthony was unable to deliver a victory to a passionate and raucous Madison Square Garden in a decisive Game 3 of an NBA playoff series. Last year it was the Celtics, and this year, it’s the Heat.

Both times, Anthony failed to deliver.

Now, as ‘Melo stares at the prospect of being swept in the first round for the third time in his career and second time as a Knick, we know the truth:

Anthony is overvalued.

That’s somewhat different from being overrated, though.

And being overrated is probably worse. Essentially, being overrated means that people believe that you’re better than you really are, and I don’t think that’s true of Anthony. At least not amongst the general basketball population.

For the most part, we all know exactly who ‘Melo is. He’s a prolific scorer who will have an advantage over an opposing defender nine times out of 10.

He’s a dangerous offensive weapon who’s most effective when he has the ball in his hands and space on the floor. What we’ve just recently found out, though, is that he’s not someone who is capable of raising the play of eight other guys and leading them to victory over a more talented team on a night when they struggle to find their mojo.

If you thought Anthony was that kind of player, you’ve overrated him. And the proof is in the numbers:

This season, Anthony’s $18.5 million salary makes him the ninth-highest paid player in the NBA. Dwight Howard, Kevin Durant, Chris Paul, Paul Pierce, and, yes, both LeBron James and Dwyane Wade, all make less.

And after Thursday night’s 70-87 loss, Anthony’s career playoff record is 16-36 (.307). He’s lost all seven of his playoff games as a member of the Knicks and is partially responsible for their NBA record 13 consecutive playoff losses.

Obviously, there are excuses in the form of injuries, roster turnover, and chemistry issues, but it gets more difficult to accept them with each loss. And it’s nearly impossible to accept them when you consider that back in 2006, Kobe Bryant and his seventh seed Lakers held a 3-1 lead over the second seed Phoenix Suns. Bryant’s Lakers squandered the series, but that he brought the likes of Kwame Brown, Smush Parker, and Luke Walton within one game of a major upset is at least commendable.

Similarly, in 2008, it took the San Antonio Spurs seven games to knock Chris Paul’s New Orleans Hornets out in the second round of the Western Conference playoffs. Paul raised the play of Peja Stojakovic, David West, and Tyson Chandler during their 57-win season.

So here’s a suggestion: Let’s hold off on proclaiming Anthony to be anywhere near the top class of NBA players until he does something equally improbable.

In fact, let’s lower the bar and wait for him to win a meaningful playoff game as a member of the Knicks. For that, we’ll probably have to wait until next April. Because even if the Knicks win Game 4 on Sunday, it’ll be delaying the inevitable, and thus is not sufficiently meaningful.

The Knicks sacrificed it all for Anthony, and in return, he’s given them nothing but a few great regular season games and one great playoff performance versus the Celtics last season. Thus far, the Knicks have gotten very little in return.

On Thursday, Anthony lost a game he had to win on a night he had to own. And it’s just the latest chapter in his Knicks book that—already—has been full of disappointments. And last night, what was more troubling than his poor shooting performance was his lack of effort, bad body language, and dearth of hustle plays.

The Heat are great because James and Wade play both ends of the court and only coast when games are in hand.

You can’t outsource will and desire. Your best player sets the tone and that’s where Anthony has failed.

The one time Anthony managed to escape the first round of the playoffs was in 2009. That postseason, Chauncey Billups—who was hurt that the Pistons traded him for Allen Iverson—scored 20.6 points, grabbed 3.8 rebounds, and dished 6.8 assists in 16 playoff games. In those games, the Nuggets went 10-6. Billups also shot 47 percent from behind the arc.

Sure, Anthony led that Nuggets team in scoring, but he didn’t lead them on the floor. That was Billups. And a leader on the floor, more than anything else, is what the Knicks are sorely lacking.

Prior to landing in Denver, Billups’ six seasons in Detroit led to six straight conference finals appearances, two Eastern Conference championships, and one NBA championship. In those six years, Billups was 69-47 (.605) in playoff games.

Anthony wasn’t able to advance out of the first round before Billups, and hasn’t been able to win a playoff game without him.

What are we to make of that?

What I make of it is that you can’t quantify difference making and leadership. And Anthony, for all that he is, isn’t a difference maker by himself. Without the right pieces and system, his gifts as a scorer will be overshadowed by his deficiencies as a player. He’s an offensive weapon who can score in a one-on-one situation on most frontcourt players in the NBA.

And sadly, if you ever thought he was more, you were wrong.

Whether it be in the first round or the conference finals, Anthony’s path to an NBA Championship will run through Miami and/or Chicago. To succeed against either of them, he’ll need solid defenders around him, guards who can dribble-penetrate, and at least one big who commands a double team when he gets the ball in the post.

No, Melo can’t galvanize a team and get them to raise their play. Some players can, and he just isn’t one of them. He might score you 50 points and singlehandedly win a game, but that’s different.

Whenever Melo runs into opposing players who can effectively guard him in one-on-one situations, his team will struggle. The sad truth is that the Heat and the Bulls will be around for a while, and so will both James and Luol Deng. It is against them that Anthony’s contributions and legacy will be measured.

Over the course of their nine-year careers, we’ve seen both James and Wade make the most with the least. James has led two different teams to the NBA Finals and has won 66 games with a Cleveland Cavaliers team that, sans him, would have struggled to make the playoffs.

Wade is a former Finals MVP who has a championship ring and elevates his game in the postseason. He missed almost the entire 2007-2008 NBA season and without him, the Heat won 15 games. The next season, Wade and the fifth-seeded Heat lost a hard-fought seventh game to the Atlanta Hawks in the first round of the 2009 NBA Playoffs.

‘Melo, on the other hand, is a guy who can score the ball pretty well.

But he is not their equal, and he is not their peer.

In him, the Knicks merely have an overvalued scorer who needs other key cogs to truly compete for the NBA crown.

The hourglass for this season is nearly empty of sand. We have seen the truth: Anthony simply can’t compete with James or Wade.

Sadly, he’s just not in their class.

And it’s about time that we all stop pretending and believing that he is.

Moke Hamilton covers the New York Knicks for SheridanHoops.com and is the Deputy Editor for CHARGED.fm. For the latest on the New York Knicks and all things NBA, follow him on Twitter.



  1. daniel says

    ouch. truth hurts. I love how the commenters who disagree don’t argue any of the author’s points, they just try to bash him as a journalist, or turn it into a LeBron thing, that’s when you know a nerve has been struck.

  2. JimmyBX says

    LMAO @METSOX. Here is a clueless twit this article usurps from the bottom dwellers of basketball knowledge from the internet..lol lmfao @ “he can’t shoot threes”…smh @ dopey ass fans who know nothing about basketball

  3. JimmyBX says

    MOKE- I say this with the utmost respect for ya. LeFraud would be holding Melo’s ballsacks if LeFraud were on the Knicks and Melo were on the Heat. This article is the same exact JUNK reporting that excites dim-witted sports fans and makes you look brilliant, but at the same time makes you look like a complete fool to guys who actually played ball against and with supremely talented individuals. At the end of the day, you should figure out who you want to cater to or who you want to emulate. Most reporters are dim-witted non-athletes who cater to the same pathetic fools who follow sports without a clue in the world what they’re talking about, because all they do is “debate” stuff without knowledge/experience. Is that what you want to be? Keep writing articles without truthful reporting instead of suggestive gobbledygook.

  4. Mtume says

    I think this is a little over pointed about Melo…without Shaq what did Dwayne Wade do?? He did not even get out of the 1st round. Carmelo Anthony has NO help on this team. Amare Stoudemire is a shell of his former self….and they have a guy who could barely walk 6 months ago playing PG. Kevin Durant, Paul Pierce and Kobe could probably not beat take this Knick team to a victory vs a very good Miami Heat team.

    ALL players need solid pieces around them to win. And I find “making his teammates better” is one of the most cliche statements I have ever heard. How do we quantify this? In wins and losses? Thats a pretty un-exact science. I also find it hilarious all the revisionist history about LeBron James that is happening right now…who around the end of the last 3 post seasons all people want to talk about is how he fails to deliver when it counts and now suddenly he is willing his team to wins??

  5. KnickKnock says

    Moke, you sure have changed your tune. It wasn’t that long ago that were defending Melo to the death on every platform, including twitter. Some of us have known from the get go that Melo and Meloball, would bring nothing but disappointment to the Knicks. Still, better late than never i suppose.

  6. Jack Knickolson says

    Deal of the Century: buy Carmelol for what he is worth, sell him for what he thinks he is worth.

  7. Metsox says

    Yeah, this is pretty spot on. I think even on the offensive end Melo is overrated. He can’t shoot the three. He isn’t great in transition. It’s basically three yards and a cloud of dust. He’s a good not great player who is wildly overpaid for what he does on the court. He certainly has value but not enough value to compensate for everything we gave up to get him. I’d rather have Gallo, cap space, and our first rounders back for sure….

    He also is a terrible fit with Amare. He is better than Amare, no question, but the tandem just doesn’t work.

    No one said being a Knicks fan was easy, that’s what the Yankees are for, although it’s a hard day for them too….


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>