Sprung: Purpose of Pierce, Garnett in question after Nets’ Game 5 loss

KGandPierceWhy did the Nets acquire Paul Pierce and Kevin Garnett from Boston last offseason, mortgaging key future assets to do so?

To help win a championship? To be on the floor in important moments in the playoffs, where their championship experience and leadership would prove invaluable to a team that previously had no players with real, legitimate postseason success?

In the most important moments in the Brooklyn Nets’ season, the final minutes of the team’s Game 5 loss in Toronto, Pierce and Garnett were tethered to the bench, expensive cheerleaders watching their team’s furious comeback come up tantalizingly short in a 115-113 loss Wednesday at Air Canada Centre.

The Nets were down by 26 in the third quarter, unglued by another aggressive Raptors offensive onslaught again led by Toronto point guard Kyle Lowry. So it made sense for Brooklyn head coach Jason Kidd to take Pierce and Garnett off the court for the remainder of the game, to rest and save them when there would be a crucial and critical moment in the series. Right?

In the moment, yes. But after the comeback was complete? Hmmm.

Leading up to Game 4 of this series, Toronto head coach Dwane Casey decided that his team needed to match Brooklyn’s effort, intensity, physicality and aggressiveness. He wanted his team to stop turning the ball over, and he would make sure his team did everything in its power defensively to contain Joe Johnson. Relative afterthoughts in the Raptors’ adjustments were Pierce and Garnett.

Pierce GarnettSo with Toronto up 85-59 with 3:29 to go in the third quarter, Garnett had played just 12 minutes, scored four points, grabbed two rebounds and registered a minus-15 while on the floor. With Pierce on the floor, Brooklyn was outscored by 31 points, his worst plus-minus since May 10, 2008.

Then, the Nets came back.

Deron Williams decided to play with effort in the fourth quarter, Joe Johnson got hot and played like the Alpha scorer Brooklyn acquired him to be, and role players were hitting shots. The Nets were on the precipice of one of the great playoff comebacks in modern history.

“Every mistake you could think about, we made in the fourth quarter,” Casey said.

The mentality of teams trying to come back from such a large deficit is to slowly chip away until the game is eventually tied. But often when the trailing team comes all the way back to pull even, it sputters and fails to finish the win because the players who executed the comeback are so physically and emotionally taxed. Brooklyn was in the position where it had two fresh future Hall-Of-Fame players who had been in pressure-packed postseason games such as Game 5 and knew what to do to win the game against a reeling and inexperienced Raptors team.

“I thought the guys on the floor were fighting and they got us back in the game,” Kidd said. “Those guys weren’t tired, so they wanted to continue to keep playing. So it was more of a rhythm…So when you have guys playing the way they did and fighting, you’ve got to leave those guys out there.”

Kidd didn’t make a single substitution in the fourth quarter until there were nine seconds left in the game. Shaun Livingston and Andrei Kirilenko came in and Pierce and Garnett just sat there, their championship experience and their fresh legs wasting away.

“I thought that group in there was going. I think it’s the best team and best group to play, they had the best momentum,” said Garnett.

Pierce said the right things too, saying that he was on the sideline cheering on his teammates.

But don’t you think those two were eager to enter the game and complete the comeback their tired teammates started?

Most importantly, if Kidd didn’t put Pierce and Garnett in the game, then why did the Nets even bother acquiring them in the first place if not for a moment and a situation like the latter stages of the fourth quarter in Game 5, on the road, of an even playoff series with the score close and the stakes higher than at any point in the season?

Let’s not forget, Brooklyn gave up three future first-round picks for these guys, four of you include the one that the Celtics have the right to swap with the Nets.

Pierce and Garnett were rested during the regular season for games like this, justified with the notion that they’d be healthy for the big moments in the playoffs. The biggest moment of the season came and went. Both players were on the bench.

One could argue that Pierce and Garnett should have been on the bench because they weren’t playing well and that better players were on the floor for the given situation. Livingston and Kirilenko are versatile defenders and Mirza Teletovic was a hot shooter who spaced the defense.

Maybe the direction of the team has changed since last June. Brook Lopez’s season-ending foot injury and the team’s 10-21 start caused the Nets to become a smaller, longer, more versatile team, and perhaps Pierce and Garnett never really fit in with that. But if Pierce and Garnett were absent from the Nets’ most important moments, it just makes you wonder why general manager Billy King acquired them in the first place.

Unless Brooklyn wins the next two games against Toronto, it will exit in the first round for the second straight year— achieving just as much success with Garnett and Pierce as without them. Those draft picks the team traded aren’t coming back, and it seems like the whole premise, purpose and point of acquiring the two former Celtics, like the Nets’ Game 5 comeback, came up just a bit short in the end.

Shlomo Sprung is a national columnist for SheridanHoops who loves advanced statistics and the way they explain what happens on the court. He is also the web editor of the Brooklyn Daily Eagle. A 2011 graduate of Columbia University’s Journalism School, he has previously worked for the New York Knicks, The Sporting News, Business Insider and other publications. His website is SprungOnSports.com. You should follow him on Twitter.


  1. says

    2 anh T Æ¡i, hôm nay có người đến chở đồ ở KhÆ°Æ¡ng Đình không?TĐT : Mai anh Tiến có ” ăn hỏi”, sẽ cố gắng thu xếp chở sớm thôi.

  2. says

    Yes I do consider November 1st the start of the Christmas season! Lots of people are putting up their decorations today, there are only 29 days now until it’s time to open the first window in my advent calender (I don’t count today as it’s not a full day left), and like you mentioned, places are starting to play Christmas music!Gosh yes I’m pumped, I’m getting all giddy and giggly answering this question!

  3. says

    Oei….. ik ben kennelijk een sentimentele muts, want ik vond het wel een mooi filmpje. De onderliggende (reclame)boodschap is me overigens geheel ontgaan.Anderzijds: Kerstmis roept sinds mijn scheiding haaks op elkaar staande gevoelens bij me op. Tegenwoordig ben ik dan ook blij als het weer achter de rug is. En de hele commerciële ellende eromheen kan me gestolen worden.

  4. says

    I鈥檝e not too long ago began some weblog, the text you present on that website seems to have helped everybody tremendously. Regards for your whole time & give good results.

  5. says

    Today, I went to the beach front with my kids. I found a sea shell and gave
    it to my 4 year old daughter and said “You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear.” She put
    the shell to her ear and screamed. There waas a hermit crab inside and it pinched
    her ear. She nevwr wanhts to go back! LoL I know this
    is completely off topic but I had too tell someone!|

    Chekea y navega por mi websiteOo listado de webs

  6. jerrytwenty-five says

    Kidd made the right decision not to play them in the 4th quarter. Had only Kidd played Blatche instead of KG in Game 4, Nets might have won that game.
    The truth is that KG is essentially Finished. Beat reporters have informed us (refer to Stefan Bondy) that KG can’t move much after games. Certainly had Billy King known this, he might have only acquired Pierce, but then with Lopez going down, it seemed like it would still work out. Nevertheless, Kidd has been trying to play KG for up to 20 mpg. The problem is that KG by himself can’t hold the Big Man responsibility against a strong Raptor line. The team has lacked any physicality every time KG is in game.
    Kidd should be using at least Andrei Kirilenko, when KG is playing, if not using Blatche or Plumlee. Kirilenko only played 3 1/2 minutes last night.

    Regarding Pierce, the only reason he didn’t play in the 4th quarter, was that Kidd wanted to stick with the players who brought the Nets back from a 26 and 22 point deficit to tying on 3 different occasions. Also, its true that Deron Williams continues to defer to Pierce, when both are playing. I wish that Kidd had realized these problems long ago.
    It should also be mentioned that multiple sources (can’t confirm reliability) have said that Deron turned down having his ankles cleaned out last summer. His ankles are still bothering him, in that he doesn’t have the same spring in his legs. Hopefully it will be done later this spring.

    What is so unfortunate, is that I believe that THIS Nets team could give the Miami Heat a run for their money. I expect the Nets to rebound tomorrow night.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>